Saturday, February 11, 2012

Universal Rights


My view of rights that people should have is different for time periods since the late 18th  Century.  Back in the time that Monarchal governments were common among nations, I feel that it was very important and necessary for people to be awarded their natural liberties, because too many of them lived substandard lives and were discriminated against based on education level or societal class.  Anytime throughout history that people have been oppressed , I think it is/was a major problem.  Each individual should have some control over their own life.  Based on the idea of humans living in the state of nature, the legitimacy of governments is founded.   Governments were formed as the best means to provide protection for groups of humans so that they could combine their abilities for the common good of all.  If it weren’t for the formation of governments, every human would be forced to fend for themselves their entire lives, which doesn’t seem very conducive to a long, peaceful life.  The problem with governments, is that all too often, once in power they begin to erode the personal liberties of all citizens and mask this action behind a need for common defense or wellbeing.

                In today’s world of more representative governments, I do believe that socially, every citizen should be given an equal opportunity to succeed and flourish.  That is where the responsibility of the government should cease, though.  Once a government affords all its citizens with an equal starting point, based in the natural rights of a human being, it should then become more hands off and let them either flourish or fail on their own.  Redistribution of property, wealth, success, should not be permitted or tolerated.  When things beyond natural rights and freedom to make decisions are given to people, it pushes a society ever so closer to losing the will to exert maximum effort to succeed.  Why would I take risks and work hard to succeed when I know that I can be lazy and the government will make up for my shortcomings a the expense of someone else.  There has never been a time that political rights should have been consolidated in one group and not another.  Everyone deserves an equal say about what they feel is the best way to live their lives.  In a free society, however, there will always be some individuals or groups that are better off than others, whether it be monetarily or educationally, and it is for this reason that different people’s opinions should be held in different merit.  For example, if there is a group that only pushes for the wellbeing of their group, and not the community as a whole, that view should not be held in the same regard as an idea that will benefit the entire community.  While all should be treated with an equality of opportunity, not all should be guaranteed equality of outcome in life.

Monday, February 6, 2012

HST 300-Module 3 Equiano's Birthplace

I think that Equiano was born somewhere in the Carribbean or in South Carolina.  I say this because of the baptism record bearing Equiano’s name as well as the Royal Navy muster that both claim his birthplace was South Carolina[1].  Further flaws in the story of Equiano come in the form of incorrect dates.  As Carey points out, Equiano is usually very accurate with information about his past, so it is suspicious that he would have flubbed the dates of such a big event like going from America to England.  As Carey also points out in his chart, Equiano’s story about his life in Africa and on the middle passage are very similar to accounts written by other authors of that time[2].  Equiano wrote of his capture from his village in Africa and about the stifling conditions on board the ship as they crossed the Atlantic.  I think his story was probably a pretty common experience for most slaves, so its not hard to conceive that he heard the story from someone else and made up a similar one about his own life.  I think the counter position is incorrect in the Carey table because there is a lack of fundamental claims that would seem to point to Equiano’s story being true.  The counter positions he most offers are just reworded from the claims that provide evidence that Equiano was born in South Carolina.  Instead of the counter arguments being assertive, they are more defensive.


[1] Carey website chart, box 1
[2] Carey website chart, box 4